Tamar

January 15, 2007
Peet's (Keeper
) novel employs separate narrative threads to track the grief of a teen puzzling out her grandfather's suicide, and the same man's youth in Holland during WWII, where he and another Dutchman worked with the British to repel the Nazi occupation. Both men have code names and fake passports: Tamar's charge is to repair the fractured local resistance movement; Dart runs the wireless, sending and receiving encrypted messages. Fear of capture constantly stalks each, but Tamar is quartered on the site of a previous mission—a farm owned by Marijke, his beautiful lover. Dart is posing as a doctor at a nearby insane asylum, staying alert for late-night transmissions by popping Benzedrine. As winter sets in, so do hunger and desperation. It becomes less clear who the enemy is, as the locals resist Tamar's leadership, and Dart misunderstands Marijke's feelings for him and her relationship with Tamar. Only one man returns to England after the war—and it is his granddaughter, also named Tamar, who receives a box of effects following his death. She then undertakes a journey to understand the box's mysterious contents. Identity confusion is a topic near and dear to teenage hearts, but Peet doesn't introduce the younger Tamar until 100 pages in, and doesn't develop her story nearly as well as her grandfather's. Comparisons to Aidan Chambers's Postcards From No Man's Land
are inevitable—readers who savored it may also take to this complex tale about how war casualties can keep accruing, generations after the battle ends. Ages 14-up.

Starred review from April 1, 2007
Gr 8 Up-This lengthy Carnegie Medal-winning novel is masterfully crafted, written in cinematic prose, and peopled by well-drawn, multidimensional characters. Intense and riveting, it is a mystery, a tale of passion, and a drama about resistance fighters in the Netherlands during World War II. The story unfolds in parallel narratives, most told by an omniscient narrator describing the resistance struggle, and fewer chapters as a narrative told by 15-year-old Tamar, the granddaughter of one of the resistance fighters. The locale and time shift between Holland in 1944 and '45 and England in 1995. The constant dangers faced by the resistance fighters as well as their determination to succeed in liberating their country from German occupation come vividly to life. Dart, Tamar, and Marijke are the main characters in this part of the book. Their loyalty to one another and the movement is palpable though love and jealousy gradually enter the story and painfully change the dynamics. Other characters jeopardize the safety of the group and intensify the life-threatening hazards they face. Peet deftly handles the developing intrigue that totally focuses readers. After her beloved grandfather commits suicide, modern-day Tamar is determined to undercover the mystery contained in a box of seemingly unrelated objects that he has left for her. Peet keeps the story going back and forth in time, and readers must wait till the end of this intricate book to understand fully what happened to these courageous people. This is an extraordinary, gripping novel."Renee Steinberg, formerly at Fieldstone Middle School, Montvale, NJ"

Copyright 2007 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

Starred review from February 1, 2007
It was her taciturn but beloved grandfather, William Hyde, who gave Tamar her strange name. But in 1995, when she was 15, he committed suicide, leaving her to wonder if she knew him at all. Later, when she opens the box of War II memorabilia that he left her, she's struck by the need to find out what it means, who he really was, and where she fits in. Tension mounts incrementally in an intricate wrapping of wartime drama and secrecy, in which Tamar finds her namesake and herself. Forming the backbone of the novel are intense, sometimes brutal events in a small Dutch town in Nazi-occupied Holland and the relationship between the girl's namesake, a member of the Dutch Resistance; Dart, a code operator assigned to help him; and Marijke, the love of his life. Peet's plot is tightly constructed, and striking, descriptive language, full of metaphor, grounds the story. Most of the characters are adults here, and to some readers, the Dutch history, though deftly woven through the story, will seem remote. But Peet's sturdy, emotionally resonant characterizations and dramatic backdrop will pull readers forward, as will the secret that gradually unravels. Despite foreshadowing, the outcome is still a stunner. Winner of Britain's 2005 Carnegie Medal, this powerful story will grow richer with each reading.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2007, American Library Association.)

March 1, 2007
Readers might think they've wandered into Ken Follett territory for this novel, winner of Britain's Carnegie Medal, about wartime heroism, treachery, and romance. After a brief prologue set in 1979, the story turns to 1944, when two Dutch nationals turned British agents, code-named Dart and Tamar, are parachuted into Nazi-occupied Holland to marshal the Resistance and prepare for the forthcoming Allied offensive. The men are housed and protected by the beautiful Marijke, who is also, secretly, Tamar's lover. As wartime dramas go, this is satisfying genre fiction; it's only when the book introduces a YA slant one hundred pages in that things become a bit awkward. We meet, in interpolated sections set in 1995, Dart and Marijke's English granddaughter, also named Tamar, who has been prompted by her grandfather's suicide to investigate the true story of her name. Dart, a cryptographer, left behind clues for Tamar to follow, but most readers will be firmly ahead of her in solving the mystery. While occasionally purple ("he wanted very much to share the secrets of Marijke Maarten's night-black eyes"), the writing is dramatic, and the covert Resistance activities are suspenseful and rich with the details of undercover warfare.

(Copyright 2007 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)